  
    
  
  
  
   
  
   
  
   
  
   
  
   
  
   
                
  | 
    
   
 Social Change 
                At What Cost? 
                Refugees 
  
There are currently around 10,400 West Papuan refugees living in East
 Awin and in border camps in Papua New Guinea and up to 150 living in
 exile overseas. The United Nations High Commission for Refugees (UNHCR)
 and the Papua New Guinea government recognises those in East Awin as
 refugees. The more than 7,000 living in border camps are not recognised
 as refugees and are therefore not receiving medical assistance. The
 only outside help is from the Kiunga Catholic mission and some Australian
 non-government organisations. 
  
During the Dutch administration of what
 was known as West New Guinea, or West Irian, there were no border
 problems with the state of Papua New Guinea, administered by Australia.
 Border crossing occured frequently by Papuan people largely unaware of
 artificial boundaries, practising traditional activities. Following the
 Indonesian takeover of the administration of West Papua in 1963 a steady
 flow of refugees fled over the border into PNG to escape political
 persecution. 
  
The number grew following the UN referendum, the so-called
 "Act of Free Choice" in 1969, in which 1025 voters chosen by the
 Indonesian authorities voted unanimously on behalf of 700,000 indigenous
 West Papuans to integrate with the Republic of Indonesia. Opponents to
 Indonesian occupation, including members of the Free Papua Movement
 (OPM - Organisasi Papua Merdeka), began seeking political asylum. The
 largest exodus took place in 1984, when over 13,000 sought asylum in
 PNG, most of whom remain today. 
  
West Papuan nationalism and support for
 the independence struggle carried on by the OPM remains strong in the
 camps. Many of the refugees are fearful of returning to
 Indonesian-controlled territory, and their presence in Papua New Guinea
 has faded from international concern and scrutiny. The PNG government
 and the UNHCR have a policy encouraging voluntary repatriation to West
 Papua. 3905 refugees have voluntarily returned to West Papua since 1985.
 However, the Indonesian government will give no formal guarantees for
 the returnees safety or a commitment not to arrest. The UNHCR in
 Jakarta does not have access to West Papua, and the representative
 of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) in Jayapura
 has been withdrawn. The reluctance of third countries like Australia
 to take West Papuan refugees remains a stumbling block for those who
 are reluctant to settle in Papua New Guinea. 
  
There are two types of
 refugee camps. Under the control of the United Nations High Commission
 for Refugees (UNHCR) and the Border Affairs Division of the PNG
 Department of Village Services and Provincial Affairs is East Awin,
 with 3,400 refugees. Funding for the large East Awin camp, located in
 PNG's Western Province, has been provided mainly by Australia (AusAID),
 and the UNHCR is committed to reducing its role in the administration.
 The other 7,000 people are in eight camps close to the border. These
 are inhabited by people who did not want to go to East Awin, into camps
 controlled by the PNG government. A handful of expatriate staff,
 missionaries and volunteers provide health services, educational and
 vocational training and small business development expertise, providing
 opportunities for wood and cane product manufacture, and marketing of
 food-stuffs. 
  
In spite of these initiatives, there are many practical
 problems facing the refugees. Water supply remains a problem. Concerns
 over land and compensation remains a tense issue between local
 landowners and refugees, with ongoing negotiations with the PNG
 authorities. Vehicle and road maintenance is a constant brake on many
 economic or social initiatives to improve camp life. 
  
Yet the main issue for the people of East Awin is not material, but
 recognition of their rights and aspirations to freedom of movement,
 granting of identity papers and travel documents, access to jobs and
 education and the gaining of residency in PNG, presently denied them,
 despite many having been in the camps for over ten years. This violates
 Articles 26, 27 and 28 of the UN Convention relating to the Status of
 Stateless Persons.
 
 
  | 
   
  | 
 
   
  "Indigenous peoples have
 the right to the restitution
 of the lands, territories and
 resources which they have
 traditionally owned or
 otherwise occupied or used,
 and which have been
 confiscated, occupied,
 used or damaged without
 their free and informed
 consent. Where this is not
 possible, they have the
 right to just and fair
 compensation. Unless
 otherwise freely agreed
 upon by the peoples
 concerned, compensation
 shall take the form of
 lands, territories and
 resources equal in
 quality, size and legal
 status."   
   
 Draft Declaration
 on the Rights
 of Indigenous
 People, The United
 Nations Commission
 on Human Rights
 
 |